How Self-Judgment & Fear of Judgment Can Get in Your Way
Episode Summary: How Self-Judgment & Fear of Judgment Can Get in Your Way
Why can the fear of being judged, or the tendency to judge yourself harshly, make it difficult to move forward? For adults with ADHD, years of criticism, perceived failures, and struggles to meet expectations can contribute to negative beliefs about themselves and heightened sensitivity to how others might perceive them.
In this episode of Reimagining Productivity with ADHD, ADHD and Executive Function Coach Marla Cummins explores what judgment is, how it differs from observing and reflecting on your behavior, and how self-judgment and fear of judgment can affect your decisions, relationships, and ability to pursue what matters to you.
You’ll learn how judgment can develop, why you might judge yourself or others, and how feeling judged can lead to withdrawal, overcompensating, or defensiveness. You’ll also learn how self-compassion, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) can help you respond to judgment differently, take responsibility for mistakes without attacking yourself, and make choices based on what matters rather than what you fear others might think.
What You’ll Learn About ADHD & Judgment
- What it means to judge yourself or others: Understand the difference between observing what happened, reflecting on your behavior, and making a negative assessment of yourself or someone else.
- How self-judgment and fear of judgment develop: Explore how years of criticism, perceived failures, and feedback from others can become internalized and influence how you see yourself and anticipate how others see you.
- Why you might judge other people: Understand how insecurity, projection, and expectations about how people should behave can contribute to negative judgments of others.
- How self-judgment can get in your way: Learn why harsh self-criticism can contribute to shame, make it harder to think creatively about solutions, and interfere with taking appropriate responsibility for mistakes or difficult situations.
- How feeling judged can affect your behavior: Explore how fear of judgment can lead to withdrawal, overcompensating, and defensiveness, potentially preventing you from advocating for yourself or pursuing opportunities.
- How to respond to judgment differently: Learn how self-compassion, CBT, and ACT can help you recognize negative judgments, question assumptions, accept what you can’t control, and take action without letting fear of judgment dictate your choices.
Transcript: Feeling Judged, Self-Judgement and Judging Others
(00:03)
Whether you’re judging yourself, feel like others are judging you, or maybe you’re even judging others, it’s likely getting in your way. Let’s explore that a bit.
You’ve tuned into Reimagining Productivity with ADHD, a podcast for ADHD adults like you, who want to learn the best strategies, tools, and skills to get your essential work done in a way that works with the way your brain is wired.
I’m Marla Cummins, an ADHD and executive function coach. And I’m glad you’re joining me today on this journey toward doing what matters most to you without trying to do it like everyone else.
What Does It Mean for ADHD Adults to Judge Themselves?
I wanna start by differentiating judgment from observing, discerning, and reflecting. When you’re observing something, you’re noticing a fac:, “I spilled the milk,” o, “I misspelled that word in the email I sent to my boss. Oops.”
And when you reflect on those facts, you might decide you wanna change something to prevent them from happening again.
(01:12)
Maybe you need to give yourself more time in the morning so you’re not rushing, which might be why you dropped the milk. Likewise, you might wanna slow down when sending an email or make sure that you actually have Grammarly turned on.
And in the midst of this noticing and reflecting, you might also discern that these are important, but not catastrophic things, and things that you can indeed change going forward. With me so far?
But when you’re judging yourself or others, though judgment could mean judging positively, the way I’m going to use it in this episode is in a negative sense. That is when you’re deciding that whatever happened reflects negatively on you or someone else.
For example, instead of thinking, “I missed the deadline because I underestimated how long the project would take,” you might think to yourself, “I am such a loser. I’m so irresponsible.”
(02:14)
“I just can’t get anything done.”
You’ve gone from noticing that you missed the deadline because you underestimated to making a negative assessment of yourself, judging yourself.
And the standard you use when you judge yourself negatively might come from maybe perceived failures or past or current criticism from teachers, family, people at work, or even friends. Criticism that maybe now you’ve internalized.
And here’s where it can get even wonkier. There are many reasons why we judge other people. Sometimes it’s about protecting our own self-esteem. Putting someone else down can temporarily make us feel better about ourselves, particularly when we’re feeling insecure.
Sometimes we project our own insecurities onto others. We may be especially critical of someone for doing something we, in fact, criticize ourselves for.
And sometimes it’s about our own expectations and beliefs about how people should behave. We’ve developed these standards for what seems acceptable, responsible, or professional.
(03:35)
And when someone does things differently, we may judge them negatively.
So when someone judges you, remember that their judgment may also have as much to do with their own insecurities, expectations, and beliefs as it has to do with anything you’ve actually done.
What Happens When ADHD Adults Judge Themselves?
And I know some of you may think that if you go easy on yourself, don’t judge yourself, you might slack off.
But what happens in my experience working with adults with ADHD is that when you judge yourself harshly, you might then feel shame that there’s something categorically wrong with you. And if this were true, which it isn’t, there would be nothing you could do to change the situation because, well, that’s just the way you are.
I’m sure you see where I’m going with this. Whatever the situation is, when you’re judging yourself and feeling shame, it’s just hopeless.
And while you’re spending your time judging yourself, you’re also probably not thinking creatively and critically about changes you might want to make, if possible, because, well, you’re just beating yourself up.
(04:53)
And if you did mess up, it could also make it harder to own it and take responsibility for what happened, if you need to, because you’re, again, so caught up in feeling bad about yourself.
And something else I’ve noticed is that adults with ADHD can be pretty quick to blame themselves and take responsibility for things that aren’t necessarily theirs to own, at least totally.
They may not step back and consider all the factors contributing to a difficult situation. Maybe there are competing demands, difficult people, insufficient resources, or expectations that are just simply hard to meet.
And yes, your executive functioning challenges may make it harder to navigate these circumstances, but that doesn’t mean everything that’s going wrong is totally your fault.
So it’s important to distinguish between what’s difficult about the situation itself, what might be outside your control, and what, if anything, you can do differently.
(06:03)
I’ll get to the alternative in a moment.
What Happens When ADHD Adults Feel Judged?
(06:07)
Likewise, when you feel judged by others, whether it’s based on something you can observe or just a perception you’re holding, that may lead you to feel even more shame and rejection.
And when you feel that way, you might respond in one of a few different ways. One is withdrawal. You may avoid those situations or people where you fear being judged, and sometimes that creates a crazy cycle. Your avoidance may lead others to pull away, reinforcing your sense of rejection.
And of course, you may miss out on opportunities because you fear being judged.
For example, one client I work with had a difficult experience with an employee, and now she’s worried that this person may be saying negative things about her to others in the same professional community. So she’s become reluctant to reach out to people in that community, even though doing so could help her find someone else that might be a better fit.
(07:13)
So her fear of what others may think is getting in the way of her moving forward constructively.
(07:21)
Another response is overcompensating. I’ve seen very accomplished adults with ADHD double down on perfectionism because they’re afraid of being judged.
They may overprepare, work harder than necessary, or feel like they need to get everything right so no one has a reason to criticize them. Sometimes we call this masking.
For example, I’m working with a physician who wants to change her working hours, but worries about how her colleagues might perceive her. She’s hesitating to advocate for something that would work better for her because of what she imagines others might think.
And in some cases, some people may act defensive. They may respond by becoming combative or immediately explaining, justifying, or defending their actions.
I’ve had this happen with clients, at least initially, before they can trust me. Sometimes what looks like defensiveness is really an attempt to protect themselves from anticipated criticism or rejection.
(08:32)
And again, when you respond in any of these ways, you may not be able to think strategically or creatively about changing the situation or even whether it needs to be changed.
Because when someone else is judging you, that doesn’t mean that you need to accept that judgment as true. People have all sorts of opinions about us, and we can’t control that, right?
And sometimes the other person’s judgment says more about their own standards and expectations than it does about you.
But before we look at how to address judgment, whether it’s of yourself or from others, let’s look at the last type: you judging others.
What Happens When ADHD Adults Judge Others?
(09:23)
When ADHD adults judge others, sometimes it’s just an expression of their own judgment of themselves. So when you’re judging others, you may also be holding yourself to the same, perhaps unrealistic, standard.
And when you’re judging others, again, you may not be reflecting on yourself and how these standards are harming you.
For example, if you’re particularly hard on yourself for being late, especially if you’ve spent years masking or overcompensating to manage time, you might also be quick to judge someone else who is late.
You may not consider the circumstances contributing to their being late or recognize that they might approach time differently than you do.
(10:18)
You may also make assumptions about someone’s intentions or character based on what you observe, particularly when your ADHD brain defaults to black-and-white thinking or even emotional impulsivity.
For example, if someone doesn’t respond to your email, maybe it triggers rejection sensitivity. And instead of sitting with that sting, you might jump straight to deciding they’re inconsiderate or don’t respect your time without pausing to consider other possible explanations or even their past track record.
Of course, judging others can harm your relationships too, because when you’re evaluating people against your own standards, you may become less curious about why they do things differently or what may be going on for them.
And that can get in the way of understanding and accepting differences, even when you don’t agree with someone’s behavior.
Separate Interpretations From The Facts
(11:27)
So to start untangling this, the first step is to notice when you’re feeling judged, judging yourself, or judging others. Not easy, for sure.
And if you’ve been listening to my podcast for a while, you know that generally the first step is to be in tune with how you feel it somatically in your body.
Is it a tightness in your head or your stomach, or maybe something you feel in your neck? That’s the first cue that you’re having an emotional reaction.
At the same time, it’s important to pay attention to the self-talk that you’re using because that’s another cue. “I’m such an idiot. She’s so selfish. Can’t they get this right?”
Obviously, these are good cues that you’ve entered the judgment zone, right?
(12:23)
Once you’re aware of this, the next step is to lay out the facts.
Be Curious About The Facts
“I dropped the milk. She didn’t talk to me at the meeting. I made a spelling error. He passed me in the hall and didn’t say hi. I got the report in late. I texted her three days ago and she has not responded. I didn’t get the job after three interviews.”
Once you have the bare facts in front of you, the next step is to get curious and ask yourself, “What could be true about these facts?”
Because again, our ADHD brain can jump straight to the worst-case scenario. Deliberately brainstorming two or three, perhaps more neutral, explanations can help loosen that grip.
Maybe your colleague didn’t say hi because they were distracted and rushing to a meeting. Maybe your friend hasn’t texted back because they’re overwhelmed or, like many of us with ADHD, they typed out a reply in their head and forgot to hit send.
(13:37)
You don’t have to know which explanation is right. You just wanna remind yourself that your first assumption isn’t the only possibility.
Lean Into Self-Compassion When Judging Yourself or Feeling Judged By Others
(13:49)
And then once you’re clear on the facts, without interpreting them or deciding what they mean, the next most helpful step is to lean into self-compassion.
And according to Dr. Kristin Neff, this means first, you are aware and mindful of your negative emotions. That is, if you’re frustrated or angry, you’re aware that you are, and you can be with these emotions without either over-identifying with them, avoiding them, or running away from them.
The next step is to realize that you’re not alone. Other people have had similar experiences to you, and depending on what they did with those facts, they may have also suffered if that is what is happening for you right now.
Then, instead of judging yourself, be kind to yourself, even, and especially when you fall short of your, yours, or others’ expectations, whether it’s related to your ADHD challenges or not.
I had the opportunity to do that this morning when I inadvertently made what, depending on your perspective, could have been a really funny comment to a neighbor, but honestly, I don’t think it landed very well.
(15:18)
I tried afterwards to extend myself self-compassion because although I’m very aware that my humor isn’t always funny to others, I don’t necessarily always catch it before it’s out there.
So though I try, I’m sure it’ll happen again.
Self- Compassion Can Lead To Compassion for Others
(15:37)
And one interesting outcome of being more self-compassionate is that you may find you’re also able to be more compassionate with others and less judgmental of them, because when you stop holding yourself to impossible standards, it naturally becomes easier to drop those same rigid expectations for other people too.
And when you do catch yourself judging someone, maybe you’re irritated that they’re running late or frustrated by how they handle the task, you can use that moment as a cue to pause and get curious.
Ask yourself, “Am I holding them to an unrealistic rule that I’ve been beating myself up with too?” Or, “What might be going on behind the scenes for them that I just can’t see?”
Shifting from criticism to curiosity doesn’t mean you have to agree with their behavior, but it does keep judgment from getting in the way of your relationships as much.
Get Support To Minimize Judgment of Yourself or Feeling Judged
(16:46)
This is also something that would be great to work with a therapist on.
For example, in cognitive behavioral therapy, you can learn more about which thoughts and assumptions contribute to your judgment or fear of judgment. Maybe you could do a deep dive into what may be contributing to it from your past, then bring it into the present by examining what you’re telling yourself, and then practicing alternative interpretations.
And in acceptance and commitment therapy, ACT, another form of therapy, you can learn to recognize that you really never know exactly what people are thinking.
You can also learn to sit with uncomfortable thoughts and feelings without, again, either running away from them or even trying to resolve whatever led to them, at least in the moment.
And then really importantly, you can make decisions about what to do next based on your values rather than letting yourself judge or fear judgment from others guide your behavior.
(18:01)
That’s it for now. I hope what you’re taking away from this episode is that judgment, whether it’s aimed at yourself, coming from others, or directed toward others, doesn’t have to run the show.
When you can pause to separate the facts from the story you’re telling yourself and then meet the moment with a little curiosity and self-compassion, you’ll be able to create space to figure out what actually works for you.
And if this resonated with you and you’re feeling like you need more help applying what you know, you might consider joining my ADHD support and education group. It’s a weekly live group where we focus on real-life challenges, and you get, yes, practical strategies and support from people who really get what you’re dealing with, and from me, I facilitate.
And if that sounds helpful, you can learn more at marlacummins.com/member. I’ll also include the link in the show notes.
(19:08)
And until next time, this has been Reimagining Productivity with ADHD. I’m Marla Cummins, reminding you that ADHD doesn’t define you, but how you work with it can shape what’s possible.
Adults with ADHD can start managing judgment by learning to distinguish between noticing what happened and making negative assumptions about themselves or others. When you make a mistake, focus on the facts rather than concluding that something is wrong with you. When you feel judged, consider whether you’re responding to something you actually know or something you’re assuming about what another person thinks. And when you catch yourself judging someone else, pause and get curious about whether you’re holding them to the same rigid standards you apply to yourself. Practicing self-compassion, questioning negative assumptions, and using strategies from Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) can help you take responsibility, navigate uncomfortable feelings, and make choices based on your values rather than judgment.
Resources To Help ADHD Adults Learn How To Manage Judgement
- Learn how to plan better with my Free Guide: 6 Common Planning Mistakes Adults with ADHD Make.
- Join other adults with ADHD and Marla in this virtual live adult ADHD education and support group.
